PRS Global Open Best Paper Awards 2020
Editor-in-Chief, Rod J. Rohrich, MD announces the 2020 awards for the Best Papers in "Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery - Global Open."
The editorial and publishing staff scoured data for all manuscripts published in 2019 to determine the number of times each article was read on Ovid and on PRSGlobalOpen.com (combined Full-Text and PDF usage) or the 16 months following article publication. This 16-month data was combined to create an average score for each manuscript, placing them on equal footing, independent of publication month. The articles were sorted by score, and selected based on pre-existing categories. This average data was combined to create a score for each manuscript, placing them on equal footing, independent of publication month. The articles were sorted by score, and selected based on pre-existing categories.
Best African Paper
Extended L-Framework: An Innovative Technique for Reconstruction of Low Nasal Dorsum by Autogenous Costal Cartilage Graft
Author: Aboul Wafa, Ahmed
I have an incredible passion regarding the topic of rhinoplasty. While working in this field, I have been confronted by many patients complaining of low nasal dorsum due to either developmental or acquired etiologies, I have decided to do something to relieve the suffering of those patients. In reviewing the literature, dorsal nasal augmentation utilizing either prosthetic implants or autogenous tissues, are the most popular techniques that have been used. I did some innovation in autogenous reconstruction of the low nasal dorsum in the form of Extended L-Framework using Costal Cartilage Graft to improve the outcomes regarding the natural appearance, long-lasting results and to avoid the "operated look." This technique has the advantages of being more anatomical and preserves the pliability of the lobule with consistent, reproducible results.
Best European Paper
Nipple Reconstruction: A Novel Triple Flap Design
Authors: Krogsgaard, Sofie; Carstensen, Lena; Thomsen, Jørn; Rose, Michael
The idea for this triple flap design for nipple reconstruction came from a patient case, where the current surgical techniques would have given a suboptimal result. Our first patient had lost her nipple due to necrosis after duct excision, however, areola remained with normal shape and size. Other techniques would have changed the shape of the areola from round to oval, but the triple flap technique recruits tissue in a more circular fashion and provides a broader base to the flaps. When the design was developed we found the technique promising, with a potential of improvement of the outcomes of nipple reconstruction. With this background we conducted the present study to evaluate the feasibility and early postoperative results with regard to complications and nipple projection as the first step in the evaluation of this novel technique.
Best Central American Paper
Personality Traits, Anxiety, and Self-esteem in Patients Seeking Cosmetic Surgery in Mexico City
Authors: Del Aguila, Estephania; Martínez, Jorge; Pablos, José; Huánuco, Marino; Encina, Victor; Rhenals, Ana
Best Asian Paper
Treatment of Horizontal Neck Wrinkles with Hyaluronic Acid Filler
Authors: Tseng, Fangwen; Yu, Hsiaoen
Horizontal neck wrinkles had been an unmet need in the past. We are contented to have found a safe and effective solution for patients bothered by such wrinkles.
Best Latin America Paper
Four-step Augmentation Mastopexy: Lift and Augmentation at Single Time (LAST)
Authors: Ono, Marcelo T.; Karner, Bruno M.
I was facing so many troubles with augmentation mastopexy that I was considering giving up this procedure! I had to find a better way!
Best Middle East Paper
Influence of Social Media on the Decision to Undergo a Cosmetic Procedure
Authors: Arab, Khalid; Barasain, Omar; Altaweel, Abdullah; Alkhayyal, Jawaher; Alshiha, Lulwah; Barasain, Rana; Alessa, Rania; Alshaalan, Hayfaa
There is a rise of cosmetic procedures in Saudi Arabia. Social media has become a popular means of advertisements for cosmetic professional providers.
Best North American Paper
The Single Incision Minimally Invasive (SIMI) Neck Lift
Author: Kaplan, Jonathan
Whether it's a FaceTime or ZOOM effect, patients are now more concerned with the appearance of their neck than ever before. This includes an older and younger cohort of patients that don’t always require a traditional full neck lift with postauricular incisions. I found that many could be treated with a single cervicomental angle incision and wide undermining to achieve their goal neckline. After performing my first several SIMI neck lifts followed by a literature review, I realized I had stumbled upon a new procedure!
Best Southeast Asia Paper
Sigma-lead Male-to-Female Gender Affirmation Surgery: Blending Cosmesis with Functionality
Authors: Kaushik, Narendra; Jindal, Omi; Bhardwaj, Devendra
Current male-to-female(MtF) sex-reassignment-surgery techniques have not been fully successful to achieve the ideal objectives. Patients report persistence of genital dysphoria with severe problems in terms of vulva aesthetics and functionality of the vagina during sexual intercourse leading to high rate of dissatisfaction and rejection by the partners. The "help-letters" from patients who had been operated with pre-existing techniques prove this point. Our innovative “true shape sigma-lead SRS: Kaushik’s technique,” has overcome the functional as well as aesthetic inadequacies for outer genitalia and vagina and has now become the technique of choice for MtF genital SRS for our patients. It has proven to be safe and reliable technique and allows faster healing, minimal dilation, and nearly natural vulva and vagina with lubricating and orgasmic capabilities. Patients who had sigma lead primary or corrective SRS have reported alleviation of genital dysphoria with extreme satisfaction and happiness in the form of successful relationship and married life. This is perhaps the largest reported series of rectosigmoid use in transsexuals carried out for primary vaginoplasty.
Best Oceanic Paper (tie)
Reduction Mammaplasty: What Cup Size Will I Be?
Authors: Chan, Marion; Lonie, Sarah; Mackay, Sean; MacGill, Kirstie
We aimed to develop a better technique to estimate resection volumes that would benefit plastic surgery trainees and junior surgeons in performing such a procedure more accurately, and also aid in satisfying patient curiosity during the initial consultation with respect to how much tissue might be excised. Our results can assist plastic surgeons in predicting the amount of breast tissue to excise to achieve a given cup size. A secondary use of these results is a breast volume guide for implant planning.
Best Oceanic Paper (tie)
The Modified Lateral Intercostal Artery Perforator Flap
Authors: Meybodi, Farid; Cocco, Annelise; Messer, David; Brown, Alexander; Kanesalingam, Kavitha; Elder, Elisabeth; Hsu, Jeremy; French, James
Best International Collaboration Gold
Soft-tissue Filler–associated Blindness
Authors: Chatrath, Vandana; Banerjee, Pooja; Goodman, Greg; Rahman, Eqram
We aimed to fill in the gap between the existing practice and knowledge about the adverse effect of blindness in relation to the use of soft-tissue fillers, so that clinicians can make evidence-based decisions. Hence why the systematic review was conducted to elucidate the occurrence of blindness with various soft-tissue fillers, the association between HA filler and blindness, and to review factors influencing the development of blindness.
Best International Collaboration Silver
Translucent and Ultrasonographic Studies of the Inferior Labial Artery for Improvement of Filler Injection Techniques
Authors: Tansatit, Tanvaa; Phumyoo, Thirawass; MCCabe, Hannah; Jitaree, Benrita
Best International Collaboration Bronze
A Simple and Low-cost Method of Sleeve to Insert Silicone Gel Breast Implants
Authors: Panczel, Georg; Munhoz, Alexandre
Breast augmentation with silicone gel implants is one of the most common breast surgery procedures. It is well described that the contact between skin and implants is described as an agent of and subclinical infection, and biofilms have also been associated with complications. In order to avoid contact between implant and skin/parenchyma, some authors introduced the concept of an implant conduit made of some materials. Others authors in the 90’s, described the "no-touch technique", based on retractors to hold the incision open and avoid skin contact. More recently many plastic surgeons consequently advocate a no-touch technique in order to minimize skin/parenchyma contamination. This is generally accomplished with a device composed of a nylon sleeve with a hydrophilic inner coating. Thus, and based on this concepts, this present article describes a low-cost sleeve adapted to insert smooth, nano-textured, and texturized implants. Our study propose an easily available option: a sterile plastic saline container that is elastic, transparent, and protects the implant during insertion. These containers are available in 500-1000 cc sizes, and is a non-PVC bag composed of several polyolefin layers. Thus our impression is that this new sleeve allows the surgeon to perform breast augmentation/revision using the no-touch technique, in a simple, reproducible, and in a more economical manner.
Best International Collaboration Honorable Mention
Consensus Opinions on Facial Beauty and Implications for Aesthetic Treatment in Middle Eastern Women
Authors: Kashmar, Mohamad; Alsufyani, Mohammed; Ghalamkarpour, Fariba; Chalouhi, Micheline; Alomer, Ghanima; Ghannam, Sahar; El Minawi, Hisham; Saedi, Babek; Hunter, Nahla; Alkobaisi, Abeer; Rafla, Karim; Zari, Shadi; Abdel Razzak Elsayed, Mohamed; Hamdan, Firas; Santangelo, Sa
Best Case Report Gold
Total Breast Reconstruction with Fat Grafting Combined with Internal Tissue Expansion
Author: Kolasinski, Jerzy
The main inspiration to write this paper come from my observation of disadvantages of breast reconstructive methods used so far. I also found some researches suggested that remote ischemic preconditioning recipient tissues improves the viability of fat transfer. This gave the idea to apply internal expansion before the fat grafting. I am aware that this is not the final solution to the problem of breast reconstruction but it shows the direction in which regenerative surgery can go.
Best Case Report Silver
Skin Necrosis following Rhinoplasty
Authors: Mrad, Mohamed; Almarghoub, Mohammed
We wrote this case report to prevent and decrease decrease the chances of such catastrophic event post rhinoplasty.
Best Case Report Bronze
A Synthetic Biodegradable Temporising Matrix in Degloving Lower Extremity Trauma Reconstruction: A Case Report
Authors: Damkat-Thomas, Lindsay; Greenwood, John; Wagstaff, Marcus J.
Honorable Mention: Best Special Topic
Cultural Competence and Ethnic Diversity in Healthcare
Author: Nair, Lakshmi; Adetayo, Oluwaseun
I was inspired to write this article based on my experience and challenges as I reflected on my journey as a black female immigrant in academic plastic surgery. I observed the paucity of diversity in the field and in healthcare. This firsthand experience motivates me to continue to mentor and sponsor individuals and trainees across all racial, ethnic, and gender backgrounds to positively impact our next generation of healthcare providers. In this paper, I work with one of my mentees to crystallize these discussions regarding the current problems in these areas and proposing practical solutions. Developing and supporting individuals and trainees in the areas of cultural competence and ethnic diversity helps to better serve a diverse patient population, improve patient outcomes, and create an environment of success for trainees, physicians, and patients across all gender, racial, and ethnic backgrounds.
Markings. Video 1 from “Vertical Augmentation Mastopexy with Implant Isolation and Tension Management”
Author: Hubbard, Thomas J.
Most surgeons are reluctant to apply true vertical mastopexy with full wedge excision to simultaneous augmentation. Doing so risks a higher capsular contracture rate due to cut parenchyma placed against the implant and even implant exposure. I found after years of experience that Mladick's muslce splitting technique solves the dilemma by completely isolating the implant with a vascular layer from the cut parenchyma above.
Best Regional Articles include the following article types as candidates: Original Articles, Special Topics, Experimental, Review Articles, Ideas & Innovations. Authors were not allowed to win twice, even for different papers or different awards. The Editor-in-Chief, Co-Editor, Editor-in-Chief Designate and the ASPS Executive Committee were ineligible.